Saturday, February 10, 2007

Cognitive Styles in Management

"When assembling self-managing work teams, the personalities of team members are often
overlooked. One personality variable known to be critical for effective decision making in
teams is cognitive style. This study sought to examine how differences and similarities in
analytic/intuitive cognitive styles affected the behavior of team members on the task/
emotionally expressive dimension identified by Bales. As hypothesized, intuitive individuals
and homogeneous intuitive teams were found to initiate more social-emotional acts. Contrary
to expectations, intuitive rather than analytic individuals and homogeneous intuitive
rather than analytic teams engaged in more task-oriented behaviors. Teams also tended to
select intuitive individuals as leaders. The possibility that different combinations of styles
may be important for overall team effectiveness was subsequently discussed, and it was suggestedthat this may depend on whether the nature of the work environment is relatively well structured and mechanistic or relatively unstructured and organic." Abstract of article from:
Armstrong, S.J., & Priola, V. (2001). Individual Differences in Cognitive Style and their Effects on Task and Social Orientations of Self-Managed Work Teams. Small Group Research, 6(2), 283-312.

This was a very interesting scientifically based study of cognitive styles on team functioning. I think that the conclusion about intuitive individuals being chosen as leaders was an interesting conclusion. As I thought about it, I realized that while homogeneity may be valued in the lower levels of employment, it's going to be creative people who are adaptable and open to new ideas who are going to be leading the way on initiatives. No matter how much alike people in the upper echelons of management seem, I would think that the majority of them at one point showed enough engenuity and innovation to get where they are.

Wednesday, February 7, 2007

Good hiring practices

As I read the posts on the Blackboard discussion group and added my own thoughts about good hiring practices, I began to think more about the process of interviewing and selecting workers. I had a very short-lived job at Target last fall and I was hired on one of their mass-hire days where they hire people on the spot, which I have always thought to be a silly practice. However, I did have a round of three interviews where they asked me the standard questions that you would expect in an interview but also some questions that threw me off, that I wouldn't expect to hear in an interview but after the post about "If you could have dinner with three people, who would they be (living or dead)?", I began to think about how questions like that can tell you a lot about a person from many different factors, including their reaction to the question, the time it takes them to answer the question as well as the answer itself.
Also along the lines of good hiring practices, people often say that government employees work and stay in government because of the high job security, the pension, insurance etc. but the government does have a very complex and involved hiring process especially the federal government and I wonder if their hiring practices lead to higher retention rates because they are placed better. I ponder this because I was recently nominated for a Presidential Management Fellowship which is a government program designed to recruit graduating graduate students to work in the federal government. At first, I was a little exasperated about the amount of steps, one had to undergo before being taken under consideration for becoming a finalist. After thinking more about hiring practices as a result of this class, I think that the multi-step process will help not only the student (and prospective employee) but also the government as the prospective employer make the best selections for the best return on their investment in an employee